Logo

Theological Editions - Indepth daily religious news, views, reviews & key theological resources
Features

In-depth religious news, views, reviews, features & resources for the thinking person
 

Resources

Bible
Sermons

Liturgy & Prayer

News & Magazines

Journals

Texts & Resources

Home

The cartoons aren’t about secular freedoms versus intolerance
by Graeme J. Davidson,
11 February 2006

The Koran doesn’t forbid images of the Prophet and representations of him are available in markets in Shiite Iran, Egypt and South Asia. Even so, Islam prohibits idolatry, and the caricatures of Mohammed as a Bedouin terrorist were a shocking insult. They’re as offensive as a cartoon of Christ crucified for paedophilia.

.... How would you feel if someone spread it around that your kid was a ‘dumb loser’? Wouldn’t your hackles rise as you rush to defend the child you love?
.... That’s how devout people feel when others mock what they love and would die for. For Muslim, Christian or Jew the love of God is at the heart of who they are – above self, family or anything else.
.... Many of us find that hard to grasp. Instead, we treat religions as ideologies that need to adjust to secular values and not inflict their dogmas on us. That’s why Denmark’s rightwing Jyllands-Posten published the caricatures of Mohammed last September. The newspaper wanted to test whether radical Islam had limited freedom of expression.
.... Cultural editor Flemming Rose justified it by insisting, “Religious feelings cannot demand special treatment in a secular society”. Really? Three years ago, his paper refused to publish cartoons lampooning Jesus. A 2004 report by the European Network Against Racism said Jyllands-Posten was particularly anti-immigrant.
.... Many who saw the caricatures wondered what the fuss was about. They seem tame compared to how we ridicule Christianity – as in South Park’s Bloody Mary episode, showing a haemorrhaging Virgin Mary, scheduled for the C4 television channel in May.
.... The Koran doesn’t forbid images of the Prophet and representations of him are available in markets in Shiite Iran, Egypt and South Asia. Even so, Islam prohibits idolatry, and the caricatures of Mohammed as a Bedouin terrorist were a shocking insult. They’re as offensive as a cartoon of Christ crucified for paedophilia.
.... All week our media has chanted that we are a secular democratic society. Translate that as meaning if the two-thirds of New Zealand residents who said they were Christian in the 2001 census have to put up with insults, Muslims can too.
.... We miss the point when we say the issue is about secularism, modernity or freedom of speech versus intolerant faith. Nor is it a clash of cultures or about whether we should arrogantly tell Muslims to lighten up. It certainly isn’t about radical Islam restricting our freedoms or about learning the truth of hard won press freedoms. That’s how ivory tower commentators and spectators with a Sunday school understanding of religion see it. It’s about when, if ever, it’s right to lampoon those we love so dearly, including our children, God, prophets and what is holy to us. Freedom of speech means we can, but it doesn’t mean we should.
.... Most of the world’s press avoided showing the cartoons, producing editorials about freedom and the need for responsibility. They said it was also wrong to publish anti-Semitic cartoons, as the Nazis did – and some Arab media still do – or child porn for readers to make up their own minds.
.... To ram home that the Mohammed caricatures were an abuse of freedoms, the Arab-European League's website showed anti-Jewish cartoons, including one of Hitler in bed with Anne Frank, while Hamshari, Iran’s main daily, ran a competition for Jewish Holocaust cartoons. The Jerusalem Post retaliated by publishing the Mohammed caricatures – proving how press freedom can fuel a global crisis.
.... Aljeezera television believes audiences need to know the consequences of violence. So it shows the gory details. New Zealand television airs a self-censored sanitised version. In France, it’s against the law to deny the Jewish and Armenian Holocausts. Our own country refused a visa to Holocaust denier David Irving in 2004.
.... All our media rejected Murray Ball’s political comment cartoons depicting a prophet.
So free expression has limits decided, seemingly in the absence of ‘hate’ laws, by popularity and bottom line ethics.
.... Despite cries of blasphemy from Roman Catholics, in 1998 Te Papa championed freedom of expression when it displayed the British artwork Virgin in a Condom. Offending our Catholics was the Museum’s bizarre way of achieving its mission to be a ‘forum for the nation to present, explore, and preserve the heritage of its cultures’.
.... Apparently, what was good for the goose wasn’t so good for the tax-fed gander. When a brewery put up a billboard near Te Papa showing drinkers at a bar with the slogan ‘Te Puba. Our Place’, the Museum, outraged at this insult to their shrine, pressured the brewery to take it down.
Prime Minister, Helen Clark accused The Dominion Post and The Press of acting gratuitously.
.... It wasn’t essential to show the cartoons when a description would suffice. But it’s unfair to abuse editors who struggled with the ethical decision of whether it was right for readers to make up their own mind and risk repercussions.
.... Religious people enjoy satire about some things in their faith, but there has to be a damned good reason to insult others – or tolerate insults to those we love.



 

 

See also
Should we intervene to prevent suicide? >> more
Divorce risk indicator >> more
When you feel like you're sharing a bed with a stranger >> more
Surving the breakup >> more
Suicide terrorism as a desperate weapon of liberation >> more
Ned Flanders — popular face of Christianity >> more
Seven common myths about religion >> more
Moral divide between church leaders and laity >> more
Unholy silence over MPs hypocrisy and greed >> more
Anglican schism over gay clergy inevitable >> more
My agonising path to enlightenment >> more
More than ever, it's a time for generosity >> more
National's ethics smell of political expediency >> more
Pope's trip to Holy Land fraught with potholes >> more
The resurrection may have been superfluous >> more
Rasputin — from sinner and seducer to saint? >> more
Religious delusions and the Jerusalem syndrome >> more
Protest mild compared with Jesus' vandalism >> more
What Castro and Obama have in common >> more
Holidays can revive romance or widen cracks between couples >> more
Dubious scholarship reinterprets Jesus to fit secular creed >> more
Furore over gay marriage echoes the conflict over slavery >> more
If only politics were as certain as dear old granny >> more
You've got to have faith to win the White House >> more
The problem of evil >> more
TV Programmers let lose Roman circus >> more
Prostitutes welcome in the kingdom of God but not in Dannevirke >> more
Church too busy navel-gazing to take lead over crime >> more
Will the Anglican Church split over gay clergy and same-sex unions? >> more
Faith in secular western society >> more
The Vatican's pelvic theology >> more
Abuse and the Beijing Olympics >> more
Would the real Jesus stand up? >> more
Hypersensitivity perverts ethics >> more
God and presidential hopefuls >> more
A three-ghetto church based on politics >> more
Good and bad intentions >> more
Deliver us from exorcists who harm >> more
How effective is prayer? >> more
Masters of non-violence, resistance and kung fu >> more
Was Mother Teresa living a lie? >> more
Double standards over child sex abuse >> more
Soppy inspirational and pseudo-spiritual emails >> more
Caring organisations and pyschopathic bosses >> more
The new anti-religious evangelists >> more
Call for religious education could backfire >> more
Blessing creatures great & small — but what about blowflies? >> more
Does God exist only in the brain? >> more
The Prudes who crucify >> more
tomb raiders and the bones of Jesus and his family? >> more
Jesus loves Osama >> more
Is God more like a matchbox or a number? >> more
Confessions of a failed axe murderer >> more
Bacchanalian festivals and sentimentality >> more
Manners: insignificant social customs? >> more
The 109 fighting boys >> more
Trying to exhume the historical Jesus >> more
Is global violence really on the increase? >> more
Polygamy, circumcision, atheist journalists and religious diversity >> more
The Christian Right stands by Israel out of a misguided theology  >> more 
What a rat taught me >> more
The Church is becoming a retirement hobby for granny clergy >> more 
Is there an anti-Christian conspiracy in Hollywood? >> more
Have church schools sold out on Christianity? >> more
How good a Christian is President George W Bush? >> more

Hitler, Lawyers, Politicians SUV owners and life after death >> more

Were the Christian hostages really idiots for peace? >> more
Infidelity: in hot pursuit of a better organsm or better intimacy? >> more
Skulduggery and controversy over discovery of religious texts >> more
The cartoons aren't about secular freedoms versus intolerance >> more

Christian Zionists hinder justice and peace in the Middle East >> more

Should making more money be your New Year's resolution? >> more
My early life as a black sheep in a nativity scene >> more
Different types of suicide bomber: what makes them tick >> more
Cheating a short cut to sucess in winner-take-all society >> more
Life after death: Is it logically possible? >> more
Is it Anglican to practise apartheid? >> more
Da Vinci Code unlocks controversy>> more
Bishops' statement: pompous, pious, out of touch and verging on the heretical >> more 
Church leaders unconvincing over prostitution law reform >> more
Divorce risk factors >> more
How global are we?  A Christian's view of globalisation >> more
Victims of dirty tricks & friendly fire: Machiavellian tactics in the Church militant >> more
A redundant resurrection >> more
War, violence, ethics, religion and hypocrisy >> more
If St Peter was interviewed for ordination today >> more
13 ways to empty a church without really trying >> more
How tolerant is the Museum of Tolerance? >> more
A church comes out and reconciliation divides >> more
Micah's dream — too much to ask? >> more
Has the revised Anglican Church in New Zealand instigated a benign form of religious apartheid? >> more
The case for St Judas Iscariot >> more
Exorcism: the ministry of deliverance >> more

Top